Will -- Execution - Proof - One attesting witness and scribe examined - Attesting witness did not state specifically that testator had seen him signing the will - Attesting witness did not state that testator signed the will in the presence of other attesting witness or the latter signed the will in the presence of testator - Held, Will not proved...........
Will -- Scribed by a scribe other than the scribe who used to scribe documents for the testator - Cannot be ipso facto termed to a be a suspicious circumstance...........
Will -- Scribe - Will scribed by Sarpanch in Urdu but signed in English at more than one place - Held, in a village, a person may be more proficient in the vernacular language than English although he may be able to sign his name in English...........
Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, Section 118 -- Pronote - Suit for recovery on the basis of pronote - Scribe of pronote and receipt not examined - Plaintiff stated in cross examination that he collected Rs.2,50,000/- by sale of his land which fact he could not prove - Amount of sale not reflected in income tax return - Held, presumption that every Negotiable Instruments..........
Will -- Scribe - Not an attesting witness - Cannot substitute the two attesting witnesses of the Will...........
Will -- Scribe - Attesting witnesses not examined - Will cannot be said to have been proved merely on basis of statement of scribe...........
Criminal Procedure Code, 1973, Section 154 -- Rape - FIR - Non-examination of scribe - Held, no, examination of scribe of FIR who was best person to give evidence as regard disclosure of identity of accused-persons by victim girls, creates a doubt on veracity of version of informants that they got FIR written and filed after knowing identity of accused-persons...........
Indian Penal Code, 1860, Section 148, 149, 452, 302 -- Seven accused entered the house of informant at night armed with country made pistols and licensed guns and caused death of deceased by firing shots at him - Trial Court convicted all of them - In appeal High Court found only appellant guilty of firing a shot at the deceased - Appeal against conviction - Held, that..........
Will -- Execution - Proof - Secondary evidence - One attesting witness and scribe died - Second attesting witness not able to speak or to more - Propounder to lead secondary evidence in order to discharge his onus of proving the Will...........
Agreement to sell -- Specific performance - Plea of fraud and misrepresentation - Except the bald statement of defendant in support of the plea there is no other corroborating evidence - A very heavy onus was on the defendant to prove fraud as execution of agreement has been fully proved by the scribe and the attesting witness - Defendant has miserably failed to prove the..........