Partition suit -- Co-sharers - Defendant and plaintiff are real brother and sister and property was purchased in joint names of parties - Execution of sale deeds in joint name itself has been admitted by defendant - Defendant was in actual possession of suit property - However, merely because plaintiff was residing separately does not mean that she has no right over suit..........
Partition suit -- Co-sharers - Execution of sale deeds in joint name of both plaintiff and defendant itself has been admitted by defendant - However, defendant has taken two contradictory pleas i.e. one that he is in exclusive owner in possession of suit property and the other, that he has become owner of suit property on basis of adverse possession - Plea of adverse..........
Civil Procedure Code, 1908, Order 39, Rule 1, 2 -- Status quo order - Parties directed to maintain status quo on spot viz. possession - Such order does not put any fetters upon parties to raise construction on the suit property - There is no need for any party to seek permission of Court for raising construction over portion of suit property which was in their possession -..........
Civil Procedure Code, 1908, Order 6, Rule 17 -- Amendment of plaint - Suit for declaration of ownership - Amendment sought to incorporate alternative relief of possession - Plaintiff was never in possession of suit property as per findings of trial Court - He had claimed ownership on basis of sale deed executed by one `S' - However, ownership of said `S' over suit property..........
Partition suit -- Partition suit and declaration of sale deed as null and void - Plaintiffs failed to establish that they are legal heirs of original pattedar - They have also miserably failed to produce cogent material to show their continuous possessions vis-a-vis possession of suit property by defendants - Defendants on the other hand have been able to show that sale..........
Limitation Act, 1963, Section 27 -- Extinguishment of right to property - Partition suit - Plaintiff though contended that he is in possession of portion of property, however, no evidence led by him that he was in possession of suit property on the date of filing of suit - S.27 of the Act thus, not given effect to rescue plaintiff's case, as he has not proved his..........
Civil Procedure Code, 1908, Order 7, Rule 11(a), (d) -- Rejection of the plaint - The plaint are to be considered under O.7.R.11 CPC - While it is true that the defendant's defence is not to be considered at this stage, this does not mean that the court must accept patently untenable claims or shut its eyes to settled principles of law and put the parties to trial, even in..........
Specific Relief Act, 1963, Section 34 -- Suit for declaration that plaintiff is deemed tenant/protected licensee of first defendant - Plaintiff and first defendant entered into agreement for conducting the business and plaintiff has taken over business under the agreement - Admittedly, first defendant is in possession of property from defendant No.2 - Agreement of..........
Partition suit -- Suit property was claimed as joint family property by plaintiffs - Defendants in their written statement, did not specifically rely on this contention, instead, they pleaded that plaintiffs had already released their share for valid consideration, which itself indicates that suit property is joint family property in nature - There is no proof by..........
Court Fees Act, 1870, Section 7(iv)(c), 7(v) -- Court fee - Suit for declaration, joint possession and permanent injunction - Plaintiffs on the one hand have claimed that they are in possession of suit properties and have sought injunction also - However, on the other hand they have prayed that if they are not found to be in possession, a decree of joint possession be..........